Here are the most common myths – and
the real story behind raising a child to be bilingual.
Myth 1. Growing up with
more than one language confuses children.
This is by far the most prevalent of
all the misconceptions. Some parents think that if a child is exposed to two
languages at the same time, he might become confused and not be able to
differentiate between them.
Experts say that "from just days
after birth, all infants can tell the difference between many languages,"
this is especially true when the languages are quite different from each other
– as different, for example, as French and Arabic.
"At that young age, infants
generally still have trouble telling two very similar languages apart, like
English from Dutch. But by about 6 months of age, they can do that too,"
Myth 2. Raising a child to
be bilingual leads to speech delays.
Some children raised bilingual do
take a little longer to start talking than those raised in monolingual
households. The delay is temporary, however, and according to experts, it's not
a general rule.
Unfortunately, parents who raise
concerns about the speech development of their bilingual child are often told
to stick to one language. This happens because in the past, bilingualism was
considered the culprit in problems with language development.
"Research indicates that
bilingualism does not cause delays in either speech or language acquisition”.
Even if your child has already been
diagnosed with some kind of speech delay, raising him bilingual won't make his
speech any more delayed.
"Studies have found that
children with language delays who are in dual language environments gain language
at the same rate as those in monolingual environments”.
Myth 3. Bilingual children
end up mixing the two languages.
Mixing languages is both inevitable
and harmless. But to some unfamiliar with bilingualism, it's proof that the
child can't really tell the languages apart.
Most children who are raised
bilingual do resort to mixing as they sort out both languages. In addition, one
of the languages often has a stronger influence on the child than the other.
Kids who have a smaller vocabulary in the minority language may draw on words
from the majority language as needed.
Experts agree that mixing is
temporary. Eventually, it goes away as a child's vocabulary develops in both
languages and he has more exposure to each one.
Myth 4. It's too late to
raise your child bilingual.
It's never too late, or too
early, to introduce your child to a second language.
The optimal time, according to
experts, seems to be from birth to 3 years – exactly when a child is learning
his first language, and his mind is still open and flexible.
The next best time for learning a
second language appears to be when kids are between 4 and 7 years old, because
they can still process multiple languages on parallel paths. In other words,
they build a second language system alongside the first and learn to speak both
languages like a native.
If your child is older than 7 and
you've been thinking about raising him bilingual, it's still not too late. The
third best time for learning a second language is from about age 8 to puberty.
After puberty, studies show, new languages are stored in a separate area of the
brain, so children have to translate or go through their native language as a
path to the new language.
Myth 5. Children are like
sponges, and they'll become bilingual without effort and in no time.
Although it's easier for children to
learn a new language the earlier they're exposed to it, even then it doesn't
happen by osmosis. It's unrealistic to expect your child to learn English by
watching countless episodes of Dora the Explorer on television.
Learning a language doesn't have to
be a chore. But introducing a second language to your children does require
some kind of structure and, most important, consistency, whether it's through
day-to-day conversation or formal instruction. The idea is to expose them to
language learning in meaningful and interesting ways that are connected to real
life.